Are HR's diversity and inclusion strategies proprietary information?
SteveCompanies suing each other after an employee leaves one company to join another, especially when the companies are competitors, over the details in the employee's non-compete agreement is not all that uncommon. Particularly in the tech industry when many rival companies are chasing many of the same kinds of tech-driven breakthrough projects like AI, self-driving vehicles, robotics, and more - the loss of a key employee or two to a rival can have significant competitive consequences and impact.
A debate can be had whether or not the entire idea of employee non-compete agreements are beneficial or necessary (or enforceable), but for the purposes of what I wanted to call to your attention today, let's all accept that for the moment such agreements do exist, and from time to time, are actively enforced by companies trying to protect their IP from escaping to a competitor, (along with the employee).
The story I wanted to highlight is about a big tech company fight over an employee non-compe
te, but not one of the ones we expect - surrounding some star engineer working on the latest VR or AI tech - it centers around HR, more specifically, around a Chief Diversity and Inclusion Officer heading to Microsoft from IBM.
Here are some details and context from coverage in Business Insider - Microsoft just hired a chief diversity officer - and IBM is suing them over it:
Tech companies have a less than stellar record hiring women and minorities. But these companies will apparently do whatever it takes — including launching a legal fight — to hire one type of person: a Chief Diversity Officer.
IBM is suing Microsoft for poaching its top diversity officer, Lindsay-Rae McIntyre in a case that could prove just how important diversity, recruitment, and retention has become for tech companies.
McIntyre, who joined IBM in 2006, was named chief diversity officer of Microsoft on Sunday, after serving in the same role and as VP of human resources at IBM. IBM, in its complaint, argues that McIntyre had access to diversity data, strategies, methodologies and initiatives that are confidential, and that she "will use, rely on or divulge" these strategies in her new role.
On Monday, IBM was granted a temporary restraining order in New York federal court, which prevents McIntyre from working for Microsoft until the court decides otherwise.
"McIntyre was at the center of highly confidential and competitively sensitive information that has fueled IBM's success in these areas," a representative for IBM said in a statement. "While we understand Microsoft's need to deal with mounting criticism of its record on diversity, IBM intends to fully enforce Ms. McIntyre's non-compete agreement to protect our competitive information."
A really interesting case it seems to me. I admit to not following the ebbs and flows and latest cases in employment law all that closely, but I do follow lots of news and I don't recall seeing a major non-compete case with this kind of profile that focuses specifically on an HR executive, and perhaps more interestingly, on specific human capital management strategies. Whatever specific policies, programs, maybe even some technology applications too that IBM, under Ms. McIntyre's leadership were employing to improve diversity, IBM is contending that these combined represent IP that is not just company confidential, but also represents relevant and demonstrable competitive advantage.
It probably matters that IBM and Microsoft are highly likely to be competing for many of the same kinds of talented people across a wide spectrum of roles. And it also probably matters that (as I have pointed out on the blog for a couple of years on the CHART OF THE DAY series), that labor markets in general are really tight, and for certain 'hard-to-find' roles are incredibly tight. Recruiting and retention ratchets up the CEO's list of priorities when the people the company needs are in high demand and when your competitors are willing to go really far to beat you in the talent game - whether recruiting new grads or poaching your top execs - like Ms. McIntyre.
The diversity angle here is interesting and timely, and probably contributed to why this was a story coverred in the general tech press. But what would be more interesting to me is to see a major non-compete battle be launched over say a CHRO or a VP of Talent, or even a Global Leader of Talent Acquisition. I'd like to see a major, Fortune 50 or so company go to battle over an HR/TA leader, contending that their particular insights, and their specific talent strategies are so important, in fact just as important as the knowledge of the latest AI hotshot, that the company is willing to battle in court to keep that HR knowledge in-house.
This is a really intriguing case, I will keep an eye on it for sure. It would be interesting and validating too, if IBM wins in this case, and HR programs and strategies are shown to be true (at least in the court's view), completive advantage. And it would be pretty cool for HR to have some more over the top recruiting and retention fights go on over HR people for once.
Have a great day!
Reader Comments (27)
Welcome high profile Chandigarh escorts service. The best escort service provide all over India. We provide high profile call girls escorts service in affordable price.
The most informative article that you have shared with us, I appreciated your sharing. Thank you
great site) Thanks a lot))
Having difficulties with a movie review? This type of writing should be detailed enough to assist the reader in making an honest decision. Here are some useful tips on a perfect movie review https://essayelites.com/movie-review/.
Have you stuck up with your task writing in different subjects, for example, Financial Accounting, Audit, Managerial Accounting, Finance, Economics, Marketing, Statistics, Law, Taxation, Human Resource Management, Operations and so forth ? You are in the correct spot. The opportunity has already come and gone to beat your rivals and score high evaluations in our direction. We help understudies in assignments of all business subjects.
https://www.goassignmenthelp.com.au/sociology-assignment-help/
Hey, it is a great post. By the way, I saw a similar article at this professional writing service https://assignmentjunkie.co.uk/do-my-dissertation-for-me/ where I bought an article a few days ago. Seems like u work as a pro writer Steve.
My Silver Taxi Service is a taxi service and airport transfer company providing a reliable and affordable private hire airport taxi cab service.
best taxi service Melbourne
There are plenty of essay writing services, so how to choose the reliable one? Read paperhelpwriting reviews from students to find trustworthy online writing company.
There’s no service like Homeworkfor.me, I love everything about it. Prices, professionalism, helpful and friendly customer support.
The most instructive article that you have imparted to us, I valued your sharing. Much obliged to you.
If you don't know what dose of CBD you need or if your use of CBD is not only useless, but also increases your symptoms. Then, you need to refer to calculating the CBD dosage. Here you can choose the optimal dose according to your weight, complexity of the symptom and several other factors.
You will be at no risk, as Acadecraft, one of the best accessibility testing companies, we follow entire guidelines for while accessing content. We meet the requirement of users for the best Testing Service with assistive tools for all platforms.
All companies should have proper HR Management System, Rules and Software, So that Non of employees have to get any harm that they havnt done Tyre Shop
Information, Appreciated. Every business have to have right HR Management System, Rules and Software, So that Non of personnel need to get any damage that they haven't done Tyre Shops Near Me
Good Content, informative and comprehensive, appreciated. Cargo Service in Dubai
Ohh my!, never knew this much about that. thanks for sharing.
Canada Immigration From Dubai
All businesses ought to have right HR Management System, Rules and Software, So that Non of personnel ought to get any damage that they havnt done Cargo Service in Ajman
All big firms and reputable companies should use the HR management softwares.
Canada Immigration From Dubai
Sand Dance tyres is a community of carrier facilities that offer car offerings for tyres, batteries, lubricants and car refurbishment in the course of the United Arab Emirates. Dunlop Tyres Our committed crew of experts can make certain that your car runs smoothly, correctly and safely, and that everybody can power effortlessly. With an intensive catalog of brilliant tyres, batteries, lubricants and merchandise for all varieties of cars (from vehicles to SUVs, etc.), there may be usually one for you. Sand dance tyres are right here to offer you the at maximum great offerings we've. We offer all type of tyre offerings and we've an excessive tech restore shop, in addition to nicely skilled mechanic who can cope with your car.
Good Content, simple, informative and comprehensive, appreciated. Tyre Shop